Never blown a butyl tube and that includes long descents off road with a fully loaded CX bike with the brakes on full. Nor have I done it on the road bikes. These fancy tubes are good for competition but not regular riding. I used to run my best race bike on latex.
I've never blown a tube either, and I've ridden butyl, latex and now tpu.
I'm not convinced the TPU tubes are for competition, most in competition will be tubeless anyway won't they?
Mine are just used for regular riding.
*Disclaimer, my gf chose her gravel bike with tubeless, but I don't run any myself.
The benefits I have seen include:
- Lighter (For sure)
- More fairy resistant (Allegedly and I've not experienced anything to disprove this, though I appreciate it is wholly subjective)
- Smaller footprint (yep)
- Easier to recycle (likely - see below)
- Lower rolling resistance than butyl (believe that is proven) but maybe not quite as low as latex.
My two best bikes also used to run latex, but being my two best bikes, it meant they didn't get ridden 'that' regularly, and so were frequently completely flat, which damaged the tyre sidewalls - with these TPU tubes, I can pump them up before putting them away for the winter, and likely just need to top them up once before they come out again - I'll check this theory this coming winter, and measure what pressure they have after 3 months - the Pirellis are outstanding, be
interesting to see how they compare with the Schwalbe, and if I have some Ridenows in by then, it can be a 3 way comparison.
If the Ridenow experiment is successful, I can see my moving every tubed bike in the household (within reason - kids bikes are probably exempt) to TPU tubes, even my gravel bike. I still have a reasonable stock of butyl ones, but my bro still uses them, so they would not go to waste.
EDIT to add recyclability thing:
- TPU Recycling:
TPU is a thermoplastic, meaning it can be melted down and reformed into new products. This makes it relatively straightforward to recycle TPU tubes and use the material for various applications.
- Butyl Recycling:
Butyl tubes, while recyclable, are often more challenging to recycle effectively. Some manufacturers do recycle butyl tubes into new tubes and other products, but a significant portion still ends up in landfills.
- Environmental Impact:
TPU's recyclability and the potential for repurposing contribute to a smaller environmental footprint compared to butyl tubes, which are more likely to end up in landfills.
In essence, while both materials can be recycled, TPU offers more flexibility and ease of recycling, making it a more sustainable option