1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Trek 5200 Snapped

Discussion in 'Bikes and Buying Advice - What Bike?' started by papereyes, 24 Oct 2007.

  1. papereyes

    papereyes New Member

    Brought my Trek 5200 in April 07 and was riding downhill on Monday.
    taking a corner when the frame literally snapped and sent me flying.

    Evans sent back to trek today, so hopefully will be able to get a replacement frame from it.

    two questions really:
    1: Wondering if anyone else experienced anything like this?
    2: What do you guys think? how could this happen?

    for me personally its a defect with the bike.

     
  2. domtyler

    domtyler Über Member

    Personally I would try and sue. Were you injured at all?
     
  3. papereyes

    papereyes New Member

    thanks Dom

    loads of scratches and cuts on my body, luckily no broken bones. Just getting over the whiplash at the moment.

    Hopefully trek will replace the bike entirely.
     
  4. Tim Bennet

    Tim Bennet Well-Known Member

    Location:
    S of Kendal
    The Trek 5200 frame has been around for some time and has sold by the tens of thousands. It was (and IIRC, still is) made by assembling cut tubes with epoxy fillets akin to traditional frame building. Although this is nowhere near as elegant or strong a method a method of construction as monocoque, it has produced a reliable frame at a reasonble cost over the past 10 (?) years. The more common trek carbon 'failure' is usually limited to the aluminium insert in either the head tube or bottom bracket shell coming loose.

    By what I can see in your pictures, it would seem there was a failure of the fillet bond onto the head tube. If there was no abuse, then this would almost certainly be due to a manufacturing fault.

    There is no question of them not replacing the frame, but they may also be more than willing to cover any consequential losses you might have incurred, as this sort of event is not good for their brand image. (Torn shorts or more.)
     
  5. Membrane

    Membrane New Member

    Ouch, that sounds and looks nasty. Personally unless an explanation can be found (previous damage done or manufacturing defect) I wouldn't want to ride the same model frame again. Hope you're ok (and welcome to the forum).
     
  6. papereyes

    papereyes New Member

    hi thanks for the warm welcome

    to be honest hoping for the new trek madone but fingers crossed lets see what happens... definetly don't want the same frame again.
     
  7. dangerousjules

    dangerousjules New Member

    WHERE THERE'S BLAME THERE'S A CLAIM!!!!!! papereyes you have evans and trek by the short and curlys only you can now f**k it up when demanding a better bike, stick to your guns!
     
  8. Panter

    Panter Just call me Chris...

    :evil: Christ thats horrendous.

    Glad you're Ok, that could've been real nasty :biggrin:
     
  9. papereyes

    papereyes New Member

    waiting to see what evans/trek say.

    personally going to ask for complete new madone bike.

    if i get any troubles i'll let you guys know.
     
  10. yenrod

    yenrod Guest

    Small frames with a short headtube have this prob.

    Its over-heated in the welding process - simply.

    You should easily get a new frame as its clearly failed ! Hands down...

    No questions asked; you should get a replacement with no problems.
     
  11. yorkshiregoth

    yorkshiregoth Master of all he surveys

    Location:
    Heathrow
    Nevermind a replacement demand a madone or else sue.
     
  12. TheDoctor

    TheDoctor Man-Machine Staff Member

    Location:
    Stevenage
    Welding? That looks like carbon to me.
     
  13. papereyes

    papereyes New Member

    TheDoctor its an all carbon frame...

    You guys think Madon 5.2 pro is going to be an equivalent model?
    or higher?
     
  14. gavintc

    gavintc Guru

    Location:
    Southsea
    It is pictures like this that pop into my head when descending fast on a twisty road. Horrible, horrible scenario. I do hope you were not too badly hurt in the process. Sh1t, that picture worries me. You really need to lay into them, with regard to the replacement. You have an excellent case for demanding more than just a like for like. They could be paying for hospital care, damages etc etc. I feel for you. I hope it has not affected your confidence too much.
     
  15. Oh xx( that looks nasty, glad to hear you are mostly OK