Walking v/s cycling

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

johnnyb47

Guru
Location
Wales
Hi and hope your all well
The last few weeks I've received some worrying news about my dad.
He's elderly and has been diagnosed with bowel cancer.
Given his age I'm quite concerned about him for obvious reasons.
When I go through worrying and stressful times I often go through spells of just getting outside to loose my self for a couple of hours a day exercising.
It seems to help a little in getting my head together.
I've got to ashamably admit my cycling has somewhat gone off the boil in recent times.
I've put on a little bit of weight but I'm not bad for the aging old f@rt I am .
So the last few weeks gone ,I've decided to going out on long brisk walks.
My knees and joints don't seem to thank me anymore to using the bike.
Cycling a 25 mile round trip, I really pay for it for the next couple of days and I somehow don't look forward to getting out to doing the next ride out again.
So back to this walking milarky I thought I would give it a try.
In all the years gone by I've never rated or enjoyed going for long walks.I've either found them boring and uneventful ,but this week gone I've actually enjoyed it.
Sporting a nice pair of Merrell walking shoes,a cheap pair of B&M ear buds connected to my favourite tunes on Spotify I've walked over 35 miles (just going out each evening doing 5 miles)
On top of that there's the other general miles you put in through just day to day walking.
After each walk my legs feel tired and achy but in a nice way instead of hurting achy that I often get from cycling.
My back/knees , neck and wrists also feel great too after a long walk which cannot be said for when I cycle.
Another thing that I'm enjoying about walking as that I don't feel as vulnerable.
I'm on the pavement as opposed to the road where I'm constantly having to keep an eye out for the traffic.
I don't have to contend with the dreaded punctures or a change into my cycling gear.
It's just a pair of shorts/t shirt and my walking boots and then head off up into the hills of Wales.
Come winter when it gets dark after work I'm thinking walking will be a much safer option to do.
I've always hated cycling on cold dark evenings along busy roads.
I know and appreciate this is a cycling forum and will most probably get some stick about my long rambling post, because I understand that cycling has/been a great thing for me over the years.
I'm quietly hoping my long to me walks each day will help me lose some weight over the coming weeks months (what do you think).
It usually takes about an 2 hours to walk 5 miles (ish)
Either way it's getting me out the house after work instead of stewing over things I can't change.
All the very best,
Johnny.
 

Drago

Legendary Member
Location
The Urban Fringe
Probably not good to be out on the road in/on any vehicle with all that going round in your head. A long walk seems just the ticket.

I too enjoy a nice stroll, a,though most of my walking is utility, walking the dogs, going the the docs, shops, etc. By 9am I've typically done 4 or 5 miles, more than most adults.ts my age manage in a week.

Im also an ear bud - or Google equivalent - user while walking. Rdiodra,as, documentaries, music, whatever. Its good thinking time.
 

Katana

Well-Known Member
To be honest I enjoy both walking as well as cycling however can’t say the same for running. In my opinion it’s not a case of one at the expense of the other! Main thing here is what you enjoy more or are more comfortable with. As far aching knees and rest from cycling could it be due to poor fit? If not maybe consider a more upright kind of a bike say hybrid or commuter that is on the assumption that you have a road bike with drop down bars? Anyway irrespective of whether you choose to cycle or walk or maybe both main things is as long as you’re comfortable and enjoy doing it. Hope it helps.
 
OP
OP
johnnyb47

johnnyb47

Guru
Location
Wales
@Katana
Yes I do have a road bike and over the years it's become ever increasing more uncomfortable to ride over long distances.
I still go out on it but those big miles I once did are now a distant memory.
@Ming the Merciless
I've heard that somewhere else (can't recall where) that walking is better for your bones
As for where I live there's plenty of forest trails literally a few minutes from my front door.
 

oxoman

Über Member
I suspect im probably younger than you lot at 61, I've found doing all 3 has helped me deal with a lot of stuff that I carried on my shoulders for decades. I did get into walking quite seriously then switched to biking and started to do a bit of running in the last 5 or 6 yrs or so. What i found was you can do one thing to death so you fall out of love with it. What I've done for the last yr or so is to mix it up and embrace the friendship ive gained from 3 forms of exercise. Try and lose yourself in the surroundings or music. As Ming says nature is a great stress reliever.
 
Location
Widnes
I find that if I am feeling bad then the constant frequency and rhythm of my feet hitting the ground in walking helps more than the spinning rhythm of cycling

but different people work differently

so do what helps you best
 

Dave7

Legendary Member
Location
Cheshire
A fellow walker here (health problems knocked my cycling on the head). For a good while I couldnt walk either (without a zimmer).
Anyway I bought an indoor treadmill which is located facing the garden and birdies.
I managed to build my legs up so now I go out most days and enjoy a 3 mile walk. There is, sadly, only 1 route if I want to avoid housing estates or without driving.

So........OP.....I agree, there is pleasure and benefit to be had from walking.
BTW.....if its relevant I am closing in on my 80th.
Keep it up and enjoy.
 
As others have said the two are not mutually exclusive - if anything I'd say walking can complement cycling nicely. It doe sound like you might want to do some mobility work and look at your fit on the bike once you're in the right head space. I suspect the bone benefits from walking compared to cycling are marginal, but hey marginal gains and all that...
 
Top Bottom