What pedals for touring?

[strofiwimple]

Have used MKS Sylvan touring pedals for years without a problem. I've never felt the need for toe clips as with a pair of firm soled astro turf trainers I have never had problems with slipping off the pedals.
I can see the advantage of dual pedals but I never go fast enough to need them

 

[hoopdriver]

MKS Sylan touring and road pedals for me - that's what i have on two if my bikes, while my dream bicycle - a bespoke Enigma lightweigh tourer - has a pair of elegant old-style T.A quill pedals. Fats for me every time, especially for touring.

 

[Iain Harper]

How would the Time X-Roc compare with the other suggestions? Anyone used them or know of an SPD equivalent?

Looking for something that combines the benefits of clipless with the occasional convenience of regular trainers/boots.

Thanks.

 

[samid]

Do those Time X-Roc have a flat platform without the clip-in thing on one side? From the pics they look similar to Time Z control that I've been using lately, they are good for clipped in riding but I don't think they would be comfortable to ride in normal shoes as both sides have the clipping device which stands out. I can ride to my mailbox (100 meters or so) and back in normal shoes but for a longer ride would put on my clipless shoes (Shimano sandals as a matter of fact).

 

[Iain Harper]

Do those Time X-Roc have a flat platform without the clip-in thing on one side?

No, I think they've got clip-ins on both sides. And they do look as though they stand proud of the platform.

Figure there must be a dual purpose (and dual sided) product on the market, but I just haven't spotted it yet.

 

[samid]

Figure there must be a dual purpose (and dual sided) product on the market, but I just haven't spotted it yet.

I'm sure you know about the SPD dual sided pedals (Shimano PD-A530) right? (I also don't know of any Time ATAC system ones unfortunately...)

 

[Iain Harper]

I'm sure you know about the SPD dual sided pedals (Shimano PD-A530) right?

Yup - and they're half-way towards what I'm after - but I was hoping there'd be something with the SPD mech on both sides, inset in such a way that the surrounding platform was still practical as a flat (but maybe requiring a non-standard cleat).

The Shimano M424 looks kind of close.

Thanks for your replies by the way - much appreciated

 

[vernon]

Yup - and they're half-way towards what I'm after - but I was hoping there'd be something with the SPD mech on both sides, inset in such a way that the surrounding platform was still practical as a flat (but maybe requiring a non-standard cleat).

The Shimano M424 looks kind of close.

Thanks for your replies by the way - much appreciated

The M424 does indeed look like it does the job but I found that the outer res=in cage is not that durable and mine started to detach itself from the outermost end.

 

[Iain Harper]

The M424 does indeed look like it does the job but I found that the outer resin cage is not that durable and mine started to detach itself from the outermost end.

Oh right - thanks - that's good to know. Will keep looking. I may need to just settle for the one-sided option

 

[BrazingSaddles]

Road bike - SPD.
Commuter - Dual side for non-commute, town riding.
Tourer - Flats, but could maybe have done with SPD's in the Alps! My main aim for sunny bike touring is to achieve a ridiculous sun tan on my feet so sandals are a must - I hate wearing full shoes on tour. Even in the rain!

 

[Headgardener]

Road bike - SPD.
Commuter - Dual side for non-commute, town riding.
Tourer - Flats, but could maybe have done with SPD's in the Alps! My main aim for sunny bike touring is to achieve a ridiculous sun tan on my feet so sandals are a must - I hate wearing full shoes on tour. Even in the rain!

SPD sandals are available from Shimano you know.

 

[samid]

SPD sandals are available from Shimano you know.

And are very excellent I must say, I have been using a pair for 5 years now, still going strong. If they get wet they dry way faster than shoes would, you mostly can do without socks (hence less stuff to wash dry etc) and for wet and cold conditions I pack a pair of GoreTex socks and thin wool socks to put under those. Works like a charm.

 

[BrazingSaddles]

SPD sandals are available from Shimano you know.

Errr, yeah, well....how do I put this without offending anyone...? Oh sod it - they're not quite my style luv! I like something a little more feminine, colourful and dainty. I am a lady, after all, and I like to remain reasonably stylish on the bike

 

[BrazingSaddles]

And are very excellent I must say, I have been using a pair for 5 years now, still going strong. If they get wet they dry way faster than shoes would, you mostly can do without socks (hence less stuff to wash dry etc) and for wet and cold conditions I pack a pair of GoreTex socks and thin wool socks to put under those. Works like a charm.

You Audax, right?!!!! That does appear to be part of the audaxing uniform you are sporting in this photo...

 

[samid]

You Audax, right?!!!! That does appear to be part of the audaxing uniform you are sporting in this photo...

No, I just tour, I took that pic after riding the Union canal path last May