Whats your Favourite Western??

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Chromatic

Legendary Member
Location
Gloucestershire
It's probably not my favourite but a western worth mentioning is The Great Silence (or The Big Silence as it was called when I saw it on Alex Cox's Moviedrome series a few years ago on the telly) It is a good film, renowned for its bleak ending. If you like spaghetti westerns and you have not seen it then give it a go.
 

theclaud

Openly Marxist
Location
Swansea
The Wild Bunch, Once Upon a Time in the West and The Searchers. Obviously. Tell me people aren't serious about Dances With Wolves?!
 

threebikesmcginty

Corn Fed Hick...
Location
...on the slake
Chromatic said:
It's probably not my favourite but a western worth mentioning is The Great Silence (or The Big Silence as it was called when I saw it on Alex Cox's Moviedrome series a few years ago on the telly) It is a good film, renowned for its bleak ending. If you like spaghetti westerns and you have not seen it then give it a go.

I mentioned it earlier in the thread - great western, you can't go far wrong with the very intense Klaus Kinski.

Did you watch the alternative 'happy' ending? - hilarious!!
 

Chromatic

Legendary Member
Location
Gloucestershire
3bm
Sorry, I missed your earlier mention. I haven't seen the happy ending, is it that bad? I do have the film on dvd, maybe the happy ending is on there as one of the bonus items, if there are any. I'll have to check.
 

threebikesmcginty

Corn Fed Hick...
Location
...on the slake
Chromatic said:
I haven't seen the happy ending, is it that bad?

In a word, yes.

I think the director was ordered to film an alternative Hollywood style 'isn't everything great' ending (by the producers I assume) and just took the p1ss - all the bad guys get shot and all the good guys are happy smiling faces. It's so out of keeping with the film's build up it would have been laughed out of the cinema. It shows how the money men have no idea.

It'll take 5 minutes of your time but if you want a good laugh....
 

zacklaws

Guru
Location
Beverley
Andy in Sig said:
There was another good comedy western where Robert Mitchum (if memory serves) plays a drunken sheriff who has to sober up to resolve a crisis.

That film was "El Dorado", where they gave Robert Mitchum a concoction of gunpowder, and other ingredients whilst he was in the cell to sober him up and make drinking repulsive so he would chuck up every time he had a drink, legged it and locked him in before he reacted to it.

Oddly enough that film was a remake of John Wayne's "Rio Bravo" with Dean Martin playing the part of the drunken sheriff.

One other scene in one of John Wayne's cavalry trilogy which I can strongly relate to in real life, is where they raid the "Sutlers store" and Wayne finds some barrels of illegal whisky and appoints his sergeant major, an Irish man (who acted in a lot of Waynes films) who likes a good drink, to get rid of it, who promptly gets all his sergeants into the store room and tells them "a real sergeants job" and they promptly set about drinking it all, resulting in them all getting drunk and Wayne jailing them.

Whilst serving in Bosnia, there was a lot of drink problems at the time, the commander in the field blamed it on spirits and instructed us to return all unopened bottles and pour the rest down the drain, not us, in the sgts mess one night we supped the lot, in fact it took two nights but that's where the story ended for us as we never got jailed, just bad hangovers.
 

DJ

Formerly known as djtheglove
theclaud said:
The Wild Bunch, Once Upon a Time in the West and The Searchers. Obviously. Tell me people aren't serious about Dances With Wolves?!


I think D with W is a lovely touchy feely film which gives the west a more humane face. What exactly dont you like about it?
 

theclaud

Openly Marxist
Location
Swansea
DJ said:
I think D with W is a lovely touchy feely film which gives the west a more humane face. What exactly dont you like about it?

That it's a touchy-feely film that gives the West a more humane face :smile:. Seriously, though - I find it terribly sentimental and (despite it being hailed for its sympathetic treatment of native Americans) I also find its racial and sexual politics on the patronising side. And I just don't like Costner, as an actor or a director. Am I being a bit harsh?
 

DJ

Formerly known as djtheglove
theclaud said:
That it's a touchy-feely film that gives the West a more humane face :smile:. Seriously, though - I find it terribly sentimental and (despite it being hailed for its sympathetic treatment of native Americans) I also find its racial and sexual politics on the patronising side. And I just don't like Costner, as an actor or a director. Am I being a bit harsh?


It's true what you say, but I am a sucker for native American Indians, I hold them in the same squishy sentimental light as this film portrays them in, so it gives me a lump in my throat everytime I watch it, pathetic I know!
Costner- Yes totally agree he is crap in both respects however again I can forgive him making me want to puke for the charm this film holds for me, once again pathetic I know.

Has anyone else seen - The assasination of Jesse James by coward Robert Ford?
 
Top Bottom