Which keeper?

[rich p]

James - not so calamitous as of old and got the self-belief

Green - incumbent and not a bad shot-stopper

Hart - Probably going to be better than the others but a bit inexperienced


FWIW, I'd probably go with James but I'm ambivalent (can you be ambivalent ina choice of 3)

 

[accountantpete]

You really wouldn't bet your house on any of them TBH.

Personally I'd go with Hart as he is the long term prospect.

 

[Flying_Monkey]

Green, but test out Hart if there are any less crucial games.

 

[darkstar]

I'd go with James early on personally, class keeper. If he proves to be a poor choice, switch to Hart.

 

[rich p]

I'd go with James early on personally, class keeper. If he proves to be a poor choice, switch to Hart.

Ah, the old Hart transplant

 

[Greedo]

In my opinion I think all 3 are pretty average tbh.

 

[Steve Austin]

Both James and Green played behind some pretty awful defences all season, and neither can be happy having picked the ball out of their nets some many times. Both good keepers

but i thinks its down to one thing, how well can they save penalties? Both Green and James are good at saving penalties, so its either one of them

 

[Paulus]

I would have David James as the no1 keeper, with Robert Green as no2.

 

[Noodley]

In my opinion I think all 3 are pretty average tbh.

I can sense this will be a standard response to any thread about England players....whatever the position they play

 

[alecstilleyedye]

I would have David James as the no1 keeper, with Robert Green as no2.

seconded

 

[Greedo]

I can sense this will be a standard response to any thread about England players....whatever the position they play

Not really

I genuinely think they have a few outstanding players and a few very good. Just don't think any of their keepers are up to much tbh!

 

[rich p]

Not really

I genuinely think they have a few outstanding players and a few very good. Just don't think any of their keepers are up to much tbh!

Kerrrrrisssst, that's a damining analysis from the land of Jim Leighton