Are we being forced to go electric?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

Baldy

Veteran
Location
ALVA
One thing that worries me, will be the availability of petrol stations in the future. If you notice, most car registrations are less then 10yrs old. So if this trend continues, electric cares will soon become the majority.

But spare a thought for those that buy a car and keep it until it dies. Our run around is now almost 20yrs old and good for a few more. Will probably scrap it when it fails the mot, but anybody buying a car today, could easily still have it in 20 yrs time - 2040 onwards. Will they still be able to buy petrol or will service stations be shut down?

Won't affect me, as I will not be driving (possibly) when I am in my 90's.

I may be reading it wrong or remembering it wrong, but I think 2030 is the cut off date for petrol/desal cars. So, service stations will be charging stations long before that date.
 

figbat

Slippery scientist
The OP appeared to suggest that fuel prices are going up as a way to "force" people into EVs. The reality is that the oil price has rocketed in the last year through a combination of factors, and the recent run on the fuel stations driven by media scaremongering has given suppliers an opportunity to capitalise. Fuel duty is fixed per litre although VAT increases with purchase price. Given the three-fold increase in oil prices you can see how little the fuel price is driven by input costs, since the overall increase is nothing like that. Let's not forget that gas prices are also high, which is driving electricity prices up too. This is a global economy situation, not some clandestine conspiracy to sell more EVs.
 

Alex321

Guru
Location
South Wales
I may be reading it wrong or remembering it wrong, but I think 2030 is the cut off date for petrol/desal cars. So, service stations will be charging stations long before that date.
That is the cut off date for the sale of new wholly IC cars. Existing ones on the road will still be usable, and hybrids will still be allowed to be sold new until 2035. The aim is to have all cars & vans on the road be zero tailpipe emission by 2050.

But as you say, we can expect filling stations to move away from stocking petrol & diesel for cars & vans well before that final 2050 date.

How many will go out of business, vs how many will become charging stations, remains to be seen, but I would personally expect most to go out of business, on the basis that most people will charge their cars at home or the office, or will want to charge them somewhere they can do something else while it is charging (such as having a meal or doing some shopping).
 

Dogtrousers

Kilometre nibbler
This just popped up on my twitter and it seems relevant so I'll throw it in.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/neilwi...c-car-revolution-and-embed-chinas-lead-report

The electric car revolution will stall in the West if supplies of crucial battery elements like lithium fail to keep up with the forecast huge increase in demand. This will drive battery prices higher, decimate profit margins, and the coveted $100 per kWh battery, which would have signaled the arrival of affordable green vehicles, will remain on the launch pad.
“Western weaknesses in lithium-ion supply chains will slow electric vehicle adoption and demonstrate China’s dominance of the EV (electric vehicle) market,” according to a report from GlobalData. a leading data and analytics company.
This kind of pressure might also delay Tesla’s long promised “affordable” $25,000 electric car.
 

figbat

Slippery scientist
Why would or should petrol stations become charging stations? You go to a petrol station because they have a bulk stock of a dangerous product and can dispense it safely in small quantities. You can get electricity in other ways without needing to go to a place that has only this purpose. I don't go to a special place to charge my phone, or drills, or anything else. Yes, scale is different but if charging takes so much longer than refuelling then I want to be doing something else whilst it's happening. Charging has to become a secondary objective of going somewhere - like shopping, eating out, cinema, whatever. I don't want to have to go to a centralised charging station and then make use of whatever facilities they have there whilst I wait.
 

Pale Rider

Legendary Member
To answer the thread title...

No.

No one is being forced to do anything. No one is forced to drive a car. The "need" to drive a car is usually not a genuine need at all, but rather simple excuse by way of justification.

Cars of any type are an environmental nightmare. If youre unhappy paying the (relatively low considering the environmental toll) price to own and drive one, then I have some advice for you - Don't

I don't want to get into a game of genuine need top trumps, but the only person entitled to lecture others on car use is the person who does without one.

Which, I'm guessing, disqualifies about 99% of contributors to this thread.
 
One condender for the hoi polloi would be rental of EVs. I could see my local shopping centre having 10/20 cars on it, chargdd, ready to go, rent for the day, the hour, wharever, take it back when youre done. Multiply that up and down the country in car parks, it might suit many people who only occasionally need a car.
I can see this working for a while, as long as it is a new idea or the only option ....

In the mid 1990s I used to rent a car as there was hire company 10 minutes walk away and a Ford dealer that did hires even closer, but I moved to owning one for cost and time reasons.

The £500, or whatever the hire company chooses, accident damage that they will reserve on your credit card, assuming that you have one to cover a broken wing mirror etc. If you have a 3 year old car you may very well get a new mirror off eBay and fit it yourself, the hire company may charge you the main dealer parts and labour rate, it's the same for that scratch that you didn't notice.

Even if these costs get built into the standard hire price but as they haven't been on ICE hire cars why would they on EVs, you still have to get to/from the collection/return point, fine for me I can cycle but I am not 75 with two dodgy hips.
 

Baldy

Veteran
Location
ALVA
That is the cut off date for the sale of new wholly IC cars. Existing ones on the road will still be usable, and hybrids will still be allowed to be sold new until 2035. The aim is to have all cars & vans on the road be zero tailpipe emission by 2050.

2050, that's no good we'll all be toast by then.
 

figbat

Slippery scientist
I don't want to get into a game of genuine need top trumps, but the only person entitled to lecture others on car use is the person does without one.

Which, I'm guessing, disqualifies about 99% of contributors to this thread.
Indeed. I have continuously owned at least one car for 33 years; I know no different. Some good friends of ours are the same age and approximate social standing as my wife and I, a married couple with a child at secondary school, both with jobs that entail domestic and international travel, with elderly and ill relatives and neither has a driving licence. They appear to have managed so far.
 

Dogtrousers

Kilometre nibbler
One condender for the hoi polloi would be rental of EVs. I could see my local shopping centre having 10/20 cars on it, chargdd, ready to go, rent for the day, the hour, wharever, take it back when youre done. Multiply that up and down the country in car parks, it might suit many people who only occasionally need a car.
Like Zip cars (but all electric).

I was all set to move over to Zip car use when it became clear that my car was headed for the knacker's yard.

It was only the fact that someone I know happened to have a little city runaround car up for sale that saved me from being able to lecture people on how well I was doing without a car.
 

byegad

Legendary Member
Location
NE England
Personally, I think car ownership is here to stay, simply because of the freedom it gives you. Many may cut down to just one car and the method of propulsion will be electric or hydrogen. Motoring is massive business so the country cannot afford to lose it.
Public transport is just not happening as it prices itself out in the UK. Unless it becomes more affordable and concentrates on providing a service rather than money driven, it won't happen.
Back in the 50s buses and trains were indeed a viable means of transport. You could get a bus from our house into town for 2d (remember them?), and parking was 6d, but only if you couldn't park on the street, which most did, for free. The relative cost of owning a car to go shopping was much more then than now in terms of income. Only the well off could buy a car.

As fewer people can afford to drive in the future I'd hope the cost and frequency of public transport will again make it viable choices for many. I've been retired 15 years, but in my working life I lived in a village and always needed a car or motorbike to get to work, until in my last two jobs, cycling became a viable choice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom