I hate throwing good, working devices away if I bought a Garmin but I have considered it; I'd have no use for the two Cateyes. And I have no need for GPS. I know my way around the county quite well. I did get a Bushnell Backtrack GPS thingy a few years ago which simply points to where I live. It can be used in a big car park for when you can't find the car. When you leave home, or when you get out of the car, just press the button so it knows where you want to return to.
I used that Bushnell GPS, too, when I used to go kayaking on Tampa Bay. The first time I went out there, when it was time to return, I had no idea where I'd launched from. The shore line is about 2 miles long and has large bushes with openings through which I launched the kayak. From out on the bay I realized I could be hours trying to find my way back. I took a guess, and when got to the shore and peeked through the bushes, my car was nowhere in sight. I took another guess as to which direction I should go along the shore, east or west. I paddled for about 45 minutes and still found no car, so I turned around and paddled the other way. Storms blow up very quickly on the bay, so it's not a good place to be lost in a kayak. With the Bushnell I could point the kayak to the spot from where I launched. GPS is a great thing. I used it on my bike when I first moved here and was exploring the county's back roads.