You can't write-off an entire group of professional HGV drivers because of the actions of one selfish and careless individual.
But is cyclists filtering on the inside a significant factor in fatalities? It seems most deaths were caused because the lorry driver rammed the cyclist from behind and killed them, or overtook then immediately turned left, crushing them.
That's what happened to Mary Bowers and Svitlana Tereschenko and Catriona Patel and all three lorry drivers were chatting on a mobile phone at the time.
You get an idiot on a bike, they may collide with a pedestrian, possibly causing a bruise. Maybe a barked shin. Bit of a scab. Rich picking.
You get a knuckle dragger in a skip lorry who doesn't know how to overtake or turn left without checking whether a cyclist is ENTIRELY predictably on the in or offside, they end up dead. It's a Cycling Super Highway. It's where cyclists are guaranteed to be. And they're getting killed. By lorry drivers.
The evidence from
Operation Mermaid, which has been going on for years and years, suggests that hauliers routinely send out onto the roads vehicles which are not compliant with current legislation. Is this pattern of behaviour, of sending out poorly managed heavy machinery to interact with the public, consistent with claims of professionalism? Obviously, I don't think so.
http://buffalobillbikeblog.wordpress.com/tag/operation-mermaid/
Turning to the issues of lorries, Inspector Aspinall told the meeting about a day of City of London spot checks on HGVs, carried out on 30 September 2008 as part of the Europe-wide Operation Mermaid, which is intended to step up levels of enforcement of road safety laws in relation to lorries. On this one day, 12 lorries were stopped randomly by City Police. Five of those lorries were involved in the construction work for the 2012 Olympics. All of the twelve lorries were breaking the law in at least one way.
Repeat: a 100 per cent criminality rate among small random sample of HGVs on the streets of central London. The offences range included overweight loads (2 cases), mechanical breaches (5 cases), driver hours breaches (5 cases), mobile phone use while driving (2 cases), driving without insurance (2 cases) and no operator license (1 case).