European Championships with spoilers

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

gsk82

Well-Known Member
I've been reading around, primarily reddit, and there's some really informative discussion about. There's effectively 2 finish lines, the painted one and a digital one. They should be, near as dammit, the same but they aren't, and can't be for various reasons. The painted one is wider for starters!

I can't do the discussions justice here by attempting to summarise but I would say that there are some genuine, albeit largely theoretical, concerns. You're in the hair-splitting domain. That said, it is a finishing line system that is used in more than just cycling and it is, generally speaking, robust and delivers the right result.

See Pidcock crossing the line first at Amstel Gold but WvA been ahead for the official photo.
 

yello

back and brave
Location
France
Sounds like the "offside toe" of cycling.

There's some of that, also some quite interesting (nerdy) technical stuff about frames per second etc. Plus also some rather intriguing almost thought experiment stuff, e.g. IF one rider hits the finish line first but the other rolls off it (i.e. the other side of it) first - who is the winner? That is, where on the broad painted finish line is the exact finish line? The digital line is obviously much much narrower.

Apparently, the difference in timings between 1st and 2nd was something like 0.0028 seconds. Sounds miniscule but (again apparently, I haven't checked the maths) at their speeds it equates to something like 4cm - now that's still small but measurable. You can how where these debates rumble on and go around in circles!
 

misforturob

Senior Member
I've been reading around, primarily reddit, and there's some really informative discussion about. There's effectively 2 finish lines, the painted one and a digital one. They should be, near as dammit, the same but they aren't, and can't be for various reasons. The painted one is wider for starters!

I can't do the discussions justice here by attempting to summarise but I would say that there are some genuine, albeit largely theoretical, concerns. You're in the hair-splitting domain. That said, it is a finishing line system that is used in more than just cycling and it is, generally speaking, robust and delivers the right result.

Similar to the Pidders vs Wout shenanigans at 2021 Amstel Gold
 

No Ta Doctor

Veteran
See Pidcock crossing the line first at Amstel Gold but WvA been ahead for the official photo.

If I remember correctly, there was a genuine issue with where the digital line was placed, that it wasn't actually anywhere near the line on the road - like the difference would have spottable with the naked eye if one wheel had been at the line and one at the photo-finish line.

Here we are:

https://www.tglyn.ch/blog/amstel_gold/

I believe that discussion may have lead to some sharpening of the rules on camera placement - I'm not sure two cameras were required at the time (and I don't think we ever saw a second camera shot from the other side at Amstel) but I haven't gone through the regs and I'm not going to.

Essentially though, the camera must be placed in front of the black line so that finish shot doesn't have a black background, and the black line is 4cm wide. The white line either side is 34cm wide I think (it's in the article above). The digital finish line ended up being quite near to the leading edge of the white line - 26cm from the black line (this is all done with some photoshop pixel counting and detective work - there are quite a lot of assumptions made - e.g. that the line is regulation width and that the camera is at 90 degrees to the road and not wonky)

I'm not sure whether anyone found there was a specific max distance from the black line in the regs, but I think anything over a couple of cm is going to result in anomalies, and if 26cm is anywhere like a realistic estimate of t´where the line was we're going to have to revisit "beat him by half a wheel"...
 

No Ta Doctor

Veteran
There's some of that, also some quite interesting (nerdy) technical stuff about frames per second etc. Plus also some rather intriguing almost thought experiment stuff, e.g. IF one rider hits the finish line first but the other rolls off it (i.e. the other side of it) first - who is the winner? That is, where on the broad painted finish line is the exact finish line? The digital line is obviously much much narrower.

Apparently, the difference in timings between 1st and 2nd was something like 0.0028 seconds. Sounds miniscule but (again apparently, I haven't checked the maths) at their speeds it equates to something like 4cm - now that's still small but measurable. You can how where these debates rumble on and go around in circles!

As an information junkie I bloody love them! :laugh:

In the article I linked (who was one of the first to start measuring pixels in photoshop) he speculates on whether you could use spoke distortion to work out wheel position at other places on the white line (ie if you decided the camera was misplaced you could adjust from that data)


Like football white lines, te actual finish line is infinitesimally small - you just need to define whether it's the leading or trailing edge of any road marking. Or in the Amstel case - neither, just a random spot before the black line
 

No Ta Doctor

Veteran
Me too. Not so much for the info (though I like the trainspotterness of it) but the questions that follow from it. A kind 'if that, then this' logic chain. Worm cans etc.

Absolutely. I want to know exactly how much difference a bike throw makes, and what the margins for error for timing it are. How big a difference does a couple of cm of line placement shadiness make to a throw?

I also worked out that at 50km/h riders would be travelling 4mm per frame of the 3500 frames/s finish photo camera, though I'm not sure why I did now. :laugh:

I'm also designing a button that will extend the rake of the forks by 15mm, which will be marketed as a ride-comfort adaption (switch between race mode and my God the council needs to repair this tarmac mode in a single click!), which will of course be reachable in the drops during a bike throw.
 

mididoctors

Veteran
He can always argue about it ...it was mad close
 

Pross

Guru
There's some of that, also some quite interesting (nerdy) technical stuff about frames per second etc. Plus also some rather intriguing almost thought experiment stuff, e.g. IF one rider hits the finish line first but the other rolls off it (i.e. the other side of it) first - who is the winner? That is, where on the broad painted finish line is the exact finish line? The digital line is obviously much much narrower.

Apparently, the difference in timings between 1st and 2nd was something like 0.0028 seconds. Sounds miniscule but (again apparently, I haven't checked the maths) at their speeds it equates to something like 4cm - now that's still small but measurable. You can how where these debates rumble on and go around in circles!

4cm works out pretty much bang on for 50km/h (3.89cm by my reckoning).
 

Archie from BR

Senior Member
The JW RR should also be on youtube tomorrow morning, another early start.
I am interested to see if Alexandria Neira can double up on her WC RR win for Spain..

Well Neira only finished 7th in the RR but she has won the TT title in the JW race, that was a terrible weak field though but all the TT fields look like that. The mens elite field is very open, still nice not to know the winner before the even.
 

No Ta Doctor

Veteran
Noval took the Jnr men's TT to double up on his WC TT as expected, but in joy for Viking fans globally, Malthe Risbjerg took the silver behind him, with only 0.03 of a second difference. Both rides would have taken a top ten in the u23. Alvarez won the u23 TT to match his WC TT gold so Spain have complete lockdown on youngster men TTing now. The spirit of Big Mig lives!


Juniors top ten:

1791375117244.png


u23 top ten
1791375165383.png
 
Top Bottom