Its like Deja Vu.
Last time there were forum changes there people who decided to say goodbye before they gave the new software a chance.
"I'm all for progress, it's change I don't like." - Mark Twain
I'm fine with the new look, personally. I think I prefer it. Either way, tho', I do think it's a bit early days for flouncing. First, because you have to give yourself a little time to get used to anything new - to get a true take on what's just unfamiliar and what you genuinely don't like - and second because this is just a starter for ten: I'm sure Shaun is carefully noting feedback, and may well fine-tune over the coming days & weeks.
The one area (so far) where I have to say I'm with the naysayers is the fragmentation of the Cafe. "Forums > Community > Food & Drink" - seriously? There's never going to be enough posts to sustain an entire section dedicated to food & drink, so why set one up? I for one would never visit any such section, so I'd miss out on the occasional - but enjoyable - food & drink-related posts that are part of the Cafe's charm. Nor, I suspect, would anyone bother posting any such - why bother, since no-one would ever see them?
Overall tho', I'd say so far so good. I like the space. It feels lighter, brighter, less claustrophobic. Either way, tho', WIP, and should be viewed as such.