First electric car experience

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.
Location
Wirral
My wife goes to many places of work in one day. Sadly a car is the only easy way to do this. I've not needed a car for work for over 30 years.

Where are you going that's got no charging stations in 350 miles ?
She could change jobs, a big probably costly change, but you seem to expect everyone else to make changes...

I want to go up to 170 miles to several destinations, I can't charge at the destination(s) so ~350 round trip. I really don't want to spend more time travelling to find a vacant/working/compatible charger to sit round for half an hour [1]as I have motorways to do that on. I can't scrap a good car, then commission another that uses more resources - and some of the resources being of questionably provenance.

[1] My current vehicle can do 800 miles between the 10 minutes it takes to fill it up, how long in total does it take to charge your BEV for 800 mile use?
 

MrGrumpy

Huge Member
Location
Fly Fifer
Used cars will be around for along time yet. Remember it’s just new cars that will be no longer supplied. The thing with EVs is the need to pre plan journeys. That’s the theme running along here !
 
She could change jobs, a big probably costly change, but you seem to expect everyone else to make changes...

I want to go up to 170 miles to several destinations, I can't charge at the destination(s) so ~350 round trip. I really don't want to spend more time travelling to find a vacant/working/compatible charger to sit round for half an hour [1]as I have motorways to do that on. I can't scrap a good car, then commission another that uses more resources - and some of the resources being of questionably provenance.

[1] My current vehicle can do 800 miles between the 10 minutes it takes to fill it up, how long in total does it take to charge your BEV for 800 mile use?

Hang on. You want me to scrap my EV ?

Our car charges overnight on the drive. We don't need to bother making trips to the petrol station and pumping petrol in the cold.

And it's not me wanting you to make changes. It's your Government. Go take this up with Johnson and co. I'm just pointing out that EVs will work for most people.
 

gzoom

Über Member
Not as straightforward as it first appears, although LiFePo initially has less range its vastly superior lifetime charge holding capacity and inherently better safety soon start to show its advantages.
Here's a link to a comparison, it gets a bit " Sciencey " in places, but it's an interesting and informative analysis of the two chemistries.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FdZL8RF3thI


Tesla however are moving to LiFePo for profit, and it looks like Model 3/Y pricing is going up again!!

https://electrek.co/2021/10/22/tesla-hikes-model-3-model-y-prices-again-deliveries-slip/
 

CXRAndy

Guru
Location
Lincs
We've got a 40kW Leaf. Summer range is 150 miles, winter 100 miles comfortably. It's all depends how you drive the car, my wife drives fast and can easily return with less than 50 miles left from a 70 mile journey. Eg she burns 100 mile range from 70 mile journey

I can on the other hand can match range to distance travelled.

Our leaf is used for school run and local shopping. We are both work from home so we just plug it back in an top up during the day for any driving in the afternoon. We have some 70k miles from 2018 model
 

CXRAndy

Guru
Location
Lincs
Used cars will be around for along time yet. Remember it’s just new cars that will be no longer supplied. The thing with EVs is the need to pre plan journeys. That’s the theme running along here !
Only for cross country trips. The actual process is, Open Google maps, select destination. Share route with car. Car works out any stops and for how long, job done.

Time 30 seconds :okay:
 

Nebulous

Guru
Location
Aberdeen
Just build some Nuclear Power stations :okay: .

That's the selfish option. Nuclear is insanely expensive, I don't think anyone has ever made it work without government subsidies.

Then you get 30-40 years of electricity and leave your descendants with a 1000 year clean up bill.
 
Location
Wirral
Tell me start point and destination I'll look at the options. Driving 150 miles is roughly 3 hours of driving time. A break is required for safety reason alone.

If you are stopping at your destination for a period of hours, then plugging into a wall socket will still give you 6-8miles per hour charge.

I can't charge at the destination as it's on street and nowhere near a socket. Nor do I want to waste more time sitting for 30minutes whatever while it recharges, assuming a charger is available and of the correct type.

Driving 3 hrs without a break is fine[1], my car would alert me if I was losing concentration in any case[2] [3]

[1] Bladder capacity/alertness is the limit I use, 3hrs is about right for my dog, my wife is fine for a good bit longer bladder wise (and sleeps more than the dog so always fresh to go), me I'm undoubtedly probably getting to the age where my bladder might limit me, my concentration is still fine [2]. BITD I drove all day with only a short fuel break of maybe 20mins, that's human or vehicle fuel, usually doing both in any case.
[2] Those little ear dangly monitors work well for most people, I did check my first one wasn't broken, my car nags my wife to take a break now just like the ear dangly did 😄.
[3] Do tell the DSA that 3 hours is too much, especially for LGV's as they are driving huge kinetic energy weapons, but you'd think they'd follow stats on concentration though.
 

CXRAndy

Guru
Location
Lincs
[3] Do tell the DSA that 3 hours is too much, especially for LGV's as they are driving huge kinetic energy weapons, but you'd think they'd follow stats on concentration though

The advice for professional truckers is

45 minutes break after 4.5 hours driving

After a period of no more than 4.5 hours of driving you must immediately take a break of at least 45 minutes unless you are taking a rest period instead. The driving period can be continuous, or made up of shorter periods totalling 4 hours 30 minutes.

A break can be split into two periods (these are known as split breaks) the first break period being a minimum of 15 minutes and the following break a minimum of 30 minutes. These breaks must be completed after 4.5 hours driving.

Breaks of less than 15 minutes would not qualify as breaks, however they wouldn’t be classed as driving time either. The EU driver’s rules and regulations state that only split breaks that show the secondary period being 30 minutes or over will be allowed.



There are further requirements for trucker drivers to limit overall hours per day, week and bi weekly. So it seems even conditioned long haul drivers are not allowed to go beyond 4.5 hours.

Yet I see poor driving standards from truckers all the time-so 4.5 hours seems excessive with poor levels of attention/concentration

Personally 2.5 hours is plenty for me.
 
Location
Wirral
The advice for professional truckers is

45 minutes break after 4.5 hours driving

After a period of no more than 4.5 hours of driving you must immediately take a break of at least 45 minutes unless you are taking a rest period instead. The driving period can be continuous, or made up of shorter periods totalling 4 hours 30 minutes.

A break can be split into two periods (these are known as split breaks) the first break period being a minimum of 15 minutes and the following break a minimum of 30 minutes. These breaks must be completed after 4.5 hours driving.

Breaks of less than 15 minutes would not qualify as breaks, however they wouldn’t be classed as driving time either. The EU driver’s rules and regulations state that only split breaks that show the secondary period being 30 minutes or over will be allowed.


There are further requirements for trucker drivers to limit overall hours per day, week and bi weekly. So it seems even conditioned long haul drivers are not allowed to go beyond 4.5 hours.

Yet I see poor driving standards from truckers all the time-so 4.5 hours seems excessive with poor levels of attention/concentration

Personally 2.5 hours is plenty for me.

I knew all of that, it being part of the spiel for a licence I hold. Perhaps self selection has a role? So me and most other of us knuckle draggers (I think we're called?) are better than most motorists (being tested x2-3 more) I concede a driver (not a car operator/motorist) also knows their limits, but most motorists have no clue.
An ordinary motorist (licence holder, but no skill) is the most dangerous beast as they have a lot of kinetic energy, bad bike riders are equally risky but generally only to themselves and vehicle paintwork.
Don't get me started on the IAM crew (been there, never again) who are just selfish...
 
Top Bottom