1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

rammed a pedestrian today

Discussion in 'Commuting' started by Trillian, 7 Mar 2008.

  1. Trillian

    Trillian New Member

    was it my fault?

    shared 2.5 m wide divided (by a large white line and clearly marked cycle markings) over a foot bridge (by which i mean it is only this path, no road or anything or i'd have been on the road)

    the path leading to it is much wider, and as such i take it a little quicker before braking onto the bridge, down to about 5mph the bridge is sloped so i have to drag the brakes to keep a slow speed

    i slow down more to actually pass people on the bridge and am on the brakes anyway when a woman walked right into my path from across the line, i bumped into her at a similar pace to two people walking into each other

    no one was hurt and she apologised quite quickly saying it was her fault
    so even though she claimed responsibility, was it my fault? had i been going any slower than the speed i was trying to hold myself to i would not be able to balance
     
  2. trustysteed

    trustysteed Guest

    it was just an accident, no-one was hurt, does it really matter about 'fault'?
     
  3. Wolf04

    Wolf04 New Member

    Location:
    Wallsend on Tyne
    Short answer: Yes
    Long answer: Yes with a but.
    We should always expect peds to do the unexpected because they usually do and even if the path is devided peds very rarely observe this. Having said that no one was hurt so everyone can put it down to experience and be more careful next time.
    I used to cycle a similar situation to the one you described and ended up going slower than walking pace after several near misses. I then decided to find a different route.
    Pete
     
  4. OP
    OP
    Trillian

    Trillian New Member

    i can't think of a way to avoid pedestrians giving me half a foot of braking room tho

    the only other route is coventry's ring road...
     
  5. Danny

    Danny Legendary Member

    Location:
    York
    Doesn't sound like it was your fault in this instance.

    There are lots of shared use cycle paths around York and you do have to learn where the places are where pedestrians are likely to stay into the cycle area, and slow right down.

    You might also consider having a bell and ringing it when you approach groups of pedestrians. Not everyone likes this, but often people don't hear or see you coming.

    Having said all that, for the most part pedestrians and cyclists in York behave sensibly and responsibly, and learn to keep out of each others' way. So hopefully your incident will prove to be a one-off. Don't beat yourself up over it.
     
  6. Carwash

    Carwash Señor Member

    Location:
    Visby
    Doesn't sound like it was your fault, no. Peds have just as much of an obligation to obey the highway code as cyclists or drivers, and it seems like you did your part.

    Had a similar incident yesterday, this time involving a large horde of school-children who filled the path like a herd of sheep, and behaved in a similar way. Of course I didn't hit anyone, and slowed to a near crawl, but 'the unexpected' was precisely what they did! Poor little lambs. :blush:
     
  7. tdr1nka

    tdr1nka Taking the biscuit

    I'm with Dannyg on the bell answer, even if you give people a start when they're not expecting you, it's preferable to being told that they didn't hear your approach.

    Ped's are very difficult to please in that, if you alert them with a bell or friedly shout, they get agitated and defencive.
    If you cycle past them at walking pace they get agitated and defencive, and if you barrel into them as they step blindly in front of you they can get extremely agitated and defencive!

    It's a bit of a NWS(No Win Situation)really, and I'd say 'NO' you were not in the wrong as you were already riding with consideration for others, and you got an apology and not an earfull!!
     
  8. Tynan

    Tynan Veteran

    Location:
    e4
    you stayed on the right side of the line and slowed down enough to allow for other parties' errors, what more could you have done to be good and reasonable?
     
  9. PrettyboyTim

    PrettyboyTim New Member

    Location:
    Brighton
    I have a little set of battery-powered speakers that also serve as a mp3 player case.
    [​IMG][​IMG]

    I've been thinking of strapping it to my bike and playing a bit of music as I ride, just so that people hear me coming...

    It's a 'Kensington Fx300', and runs off two AAA batteries.
     
  10. Stig-OT-Dump

    Stig-OT-Dump Über Member

    Not your fault but you probably could have done more to avoid it.

    I have never had anyone object to a shout of "coming through" when I have had right of way and they have always reacted appropriately....




    ...except for an incident with Mrs Stig, that I really don't want to go into on a public forum.
     
  11. domtyler

    domtyler Über Member

    I suggest you invest in an Airzound! :blush:

    I would not say that any blame whatsoever could be laid at your feet for this one. She should have looked before moving onto the bike track. Pure and simple.

    Why should you have to tinkle a little bell? You say you were moving at a similar speed to someone walking, do you carry a little bell to tinkle at people when you are out for a stroll?
     
  12. Landslide

    Landslide Rare Migrant

    Location:
    Called to the bar
    I'll take a large 99 with raspberry sauce please!
     
  13. I have two car/motorcycle? horns now and they work a treat.:blush:
     
  14. Monkey Boy

    Monkey Boy New Member

    Did you get her number????
     
  15. domtyler

    domtyler Über Member

    Have you reconfigured them to play Greensleeves?