Shin splints anyone ?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

presta

Legendary Member
I might be wrong on this but are not trainers that are designed for running built for landing the front of your foot first these days. Where as when you walk you heel strike.
You might be better with some walking/ approach shoes.

Some of the training shoes I see have soles that protrude at the back of the heel, which seems to me like they've been deliberately designed to aggravate heel strike:

1786628570343.png
 

Webbo2

Veteran
I really dont know, the 1st part sounds right but in my running days it was heel first the roll onto towards the front.

These most runners I see seem to land on the ball of their foot. I agree in my day too it was heel first.
 
These most runners I see seem to land on the ball of their foot. I agree in my day too it was heel first.

I was always heal first until I started to suffer with my knees. I then went to toes for a while but it did`nt seem natural (to me anyway). I had a lay off and concentrated on cycling. When I then tried to run again, I no longer could run. It seems daft but it is as if the brain is confused. Cycling it has to be.
 

Webbo2

Veteran
I was always heal first until I started to suffer with my knees. I then went to toes for a while but it did`nt seem natural (to me anyway). I had a lay off and concentrated on cycling. When I then tried to run again, I no longer could run. It seems daft but it is as if the brain is confused. Cycling it has to be.

I find when I’m crossing the road and suddenly need to break in to a run to avoid traffic I really have to think about it in order to get going.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
I've started suffering. And the one question in my mind that nobody would be able to answer is "How long to recover?" - as I guess much depends on how bad the damage is (between minor to stress fracture) plus how well I rest it/stretch muscles).

Probably my fault as I'm still recovering from a torn knee ligament (same leg) and inflamed knee bursa/fat pad (same leg) so maybe agravated by maybe walking/cycling with slightly different muscle use?

But probably worst of all is the way my mind works - massive over determination. So if I head out for a short ride and get tired or knee pain, etc. I won't do the intended short ride but "I won't be beaten by it" so what was short becomes longer so no way did "I succumb".

So I've been doing a lot of longer than usual walks as I refuse to let knee pain stop my activity.

And last ride before things went bad was to be a short ride but (on recumbent) 1st push on pedals and pain and my "will not be beaten" cut in and I ended up not getting home until dusk and every pedal turn bad leg hurt. Stupid but excessive determination that is getting worse as I get older. Personal failing.
 

Jameshow

Guru
I'd definitely say get some more comfy shoes with some cushioning in. I did a 10k the other day in my old trainers having put new ones one for several weeks. The old ones gave me shin splints.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
I'd definitely say get some more comfy shoes with some cushioning in. I did a 10k the other day in my old trainers having put new ones one for several weeks. The old ones gave me shin splints.
In my case I'm pretty sure shoes are OK (professionally fitted walking boots with good orthotic soles and on bike, SPD sandals so pushing through ball of foot).

I think my cause was my psychological issue where "I won't be beaten by myself" meaning pain just causes me to go further and harder to fool myself these things are not limiting me. Something that has got a lot worse as I'm getting older and something I need to find a way to resolve.
 

Phil4000

Well-Known Member
My shins are practically numb from martial arts, miracle I don't have shin splints.
I have an arthritic big toe, from multiple breaks. Its limited my kicking and running.

What's been a miracle discovery of taking up biking this year, is that there's no strain on the toes. Have a minor knee injury that prevents walking as normal (getting better fast), but no problem with cycling.

What I'd say is, concentrate on the use of your calf muscle when cycling and apply that to walking/standing. You want the weight to the calf and not the shin. Maybe that you've been doing too much with the shin and not the calf, hence the strain.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
You want the weight to the calf and not the shin. Maybe that you've been doing too much with the shin and not the calf, hence the strain.
I'm on a recumbent where I believe the muscle use is a bit different (hence the "getting bent legs" expression). It was a recumbent ride that really made things worse (which I should have abandoned after the first 10 meters). On the upright both the knee and shins seem to cope OK ... except not just walkign across the kitchen is painful I'm giving everything a rest.
 

Phil4000

Well-Known Member
I'm on a recumbent where I believe the muscle use is a bit different (hence the "getting bent legs" expression). It was a recumbent ride that really made things worse (which I should have abandoned after the first 10 meters). On the upright both the knee and shins seem to cope OK ... except not just walkign across the kitchen is painful I'm giving everything a rest.
Are you warming up and warming down after a ride?

Yes, rest in the initial stages of pain. Then get back to it gently.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
Are you warming up and warming down after a ride?

Yes, rest in the initial stages of pain. Then get back to it gently.
Am. Done a fair few miles often much higher daily mileages on the recumbent (and upright and walks) than recently so pretty sure it's been caused indirectly from my torn knee ligament. I'm no medic but physio said that when one muscle suffers an issue others try to take the load or avoid pain) yet are not designed to and not accustomed to so it becomes more likely they'll start suffering as well.

Just having a moan onine as I really don't cope well with not getting out and getting fresh air, change of scenery and some exercise. It's a broader concern as I get older, worry that as I lose mobility so I'll get more frustrated and unhappy with being indoors ...
 

Phil4000

Well-Known Member
Am. Done a fair few miles often much higher daily mileages on the recumbent (and upright and walks) than recently so pretty sure it's been caused indirectly from my torn knee ligament. I'm no medic but physio said that when one muscle suffers an issue others try to take the load or avoid pain) yet are not designed to and not accustomed to so it becomes more likely they'll start suffering as well.

Just having a moan onine as I really don't cope well with not getting out and getting fresh air, change of scenery and some exercise. It's a broader concern as I get older, worry that as I lose mobility so I'll get more frustrated and unhappy with being indoors ...
Yes, when a ligament is injured other postural muscles in the body work harder to compensate. They key is to make sure those postural muscles do not continue to overwork, when the injury has been resolved. As that will lead to long term postural misalignment, back issues etc.

That's one reason why the rest period is so important.

Then adapt stretching and relaxing, as part of your workout routine. This is key not only to the resolution of injuries, but also in their prevention, and continuing to be active in older age. (All ages really)

We'll align our brakes and wheels, the body needs the same care.
 

nogoodnamesleft

Über Member
Yes, when a ligament is injured other postural muscles in the body work harder to compensate. They key is to make sure those postural muscles do not continue to overwork, when the injury has been resolved. As that will lead to long term postural misalignment, back issues etc.

That's one reason why the rest period is so important.

Then adapt stretching and relaxing, as part of your workout routine. This is key not only to the resolution of injuries, but also in their prevention, and continuing to be active in older age. (All ages really)

We'll align our brakes and wheels, the body needs the same care.
Many thanks.
I'm always pretty careful about internet medical advice (and rejecting a lot of sources) but I am following the stretching advice from https://www.geh.nhs.uk/patients-and-visitors/patients/patient-leaflets/shin-splints (which I've assumed is safe as it's UK NHS). Been doing some of the stretches they recommend - with just me ie no control group, it's difficult to know effects but certainly they don't seem to be making anything worse.

Torn knee ligament & inflamed bursa/fat pad were diagnosed by professional physio but shin splits seemed to me to be pretty self evident so I've gone with self diagnosis (for the moment).
 

Jameshow

Guru
If your walking on tarmac getting a pair of hoka trainers or trail shoes - would do wonders! Walking shoes aren't always very cushioned.
 
Top Bottom