Who's at fault....Lorry driver, cyclist or the cycle lane designer?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

benb

Evidence based cyclist
Location
Epsom
I said the cyclist is a risk to other road users, not just the lorry.
So no cycling licence then, so anyone can just get on a bike and cycle without knowing what signs mean, what road positioning they should use etc. Surely that is a risk to other road users?

How many other road users are KSI by dangerous cyclists?
 

Mugshot

Cracking a solo.
How many other road users are KSI by dangerous cyclists?
What's KSI please benb?
 

Mugshot

Cracking a solo.
Killed or Seriously Injured.
Thank you.
OT, when I was employed in retail rather than being self employed in retail, within the company I worked for a KSI meant KEY STAGE INDICATOR which referred to training modules and how the trainee was progressing through them at particular points.
 

cd365

Guru
Location
Coventry, uk
How many other road users are KSI by dangerous cyclists?

Even if the figure was 1 then 1 is too many. The point is everyone should take care on the road, they have a responsibility to themselves and everyone around them. Too many times the finger is wagged at the motorist cause they are in the bigger vehicle. When I'm out and about the person primary responsible to make sure I'm not hurt in any way is me. The maneuver the cyclist made was dangerous to him but he still did it and got hurt. If he hadn't made that dangerous maneuver he wouldn't have got hurt, simples!
 

BentMikey

Rider of Seolferwulf
Location
South London
From my point of view, and speaking generally, the finger isn't pointed at motorists nearly enough. Look at the kill rate:

As a point of comparison: since 2001, 576 British soldiers have been killed in Afghanistan and Iraq; 1,275 cyclists died on British streets. The latest data shows there were 1,850 deaths or serious injuries in the first half of 2011, a 12 per cent rise on the year before.

http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/public/cyclesafety/article3306502.ece

On the other hand, here in this incident specifically, I'm finding it hard to blame the lorry driver to any large degree.
 

cd365

Guru
Location
Coventry, uk
I agree, if a motorist maims or kills then they should be punished just as much as an attacker with a knife would be. Especially those who drink and drive.
 

benb

Evidence based cyclist
Location
Epsom
Even if the figure was 1 then 1 is too many. The point is everyone should take care on the road, they have a responsibility to themselves and everyone around them. Too many times the finger is wagged at the motorist cause they are in the bigger vehicle. When I'm out and about the person primary responsible to make sure I'm not hurt in any way is me. The maneuver the cyclist made was dangerous to him but he still did it and got hurt. If he hadn't made that dangerous maneuver he wouldn't have got hurt, simples!

Well, OK, but if you are trying to make the roads safer, then it's obvious where you should be concentrating your efforts.
 

subaqua

What’s the point
Location
Leytonstone
I blame John Terry
 

Mushroomgodmat

Über Member
Location
Norwich
I agree, if a motorist maims or kills then they should be punished just as much as an attacker with a knife would be. Especially those who drink and drive.

Are you assuming then that premeditated murder should carry the same charge as accidental murder, or murder by recklessness?
If that's the case I strongly disagree.
 

dawesome

Senior Member
Are you assuming then that premeditated murder should carry the same charge as accidental murder, or murder by recklessness?
If that's the case I strongly disagree.


No such thing as "accidental murder" but if a lorry driver is drunk,speeding, chatting on a mobile, has fiddled the tacho or knowingly taken an unsafe, illegal vehicle on the roads it is no more an "accident" than a death caused by firing a gun along a crowded high street.
 

Mushroomgodmat

Über Member
Location
Norwich
No such thing as "accidental murder" but if a lorry driver is drunk,speeding, chatting on a mobile, has fiddled the tacho or knowingly taken an unsafe, illegal vehicle on the roads it is no more an "accident" than a death caused by firing a gun along a crowded high street.


Manslaughter is the definition of accidental murder.
 

cd365

Guru
Location
Coventry, uk
Well, OK, but if you are trying to make the roads safer, then it's obvious where you should be concentrating your efforts.
Where is this, having never met me you seem to know my driving and riding skills. Being the perfect road user I'm surprised you are not a special adviser to the Government.
 

benb

Evidence based cyclist
Location
Epsom
Where is this, having never met me you seem to know my driving and riding skills. Being the perfect road user I'm surprised you are not a special adviser to the Government.

What?
What I wrote made no comment on your, or my, riding or driving skills.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom