Why did pedals you can ride in any shoe go out of fashion?

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

KneesUp

Guru
After the downpours of last week I've put my steel road bike in the cellar for the winter and swapped to a recent eBay purchased aluminium hybrid with disc brakes for the winter commute.

My commute is only short (5km ish) so I don't get all kitted up to ride it; I have a cape for rainy days which does a good enough job keeping my dry, and otherwise I just ride in my work stuff and maybe a cycling jacket. It's all downhill on the way in, so I don't have to worry about getting too hot.

Anyway - the steel bike, being older, has steel pedals and small toe clips with no straps, which keep my feet on the pedals even when it rains, but the pedals are smooth.

The hybrid has come with huge flat pedals with pins on them - which admittedly does mean your foot doesn't slip off, but when you need to lift a pedal to reposition it for getting going at lights and so on, the pins wreck your shoes. Ask me how I know.

I'm not at work today so thought I'd pick up some new pedals for it - I don't want anything fancy. Just what I consider normal pedals. However, all the places I might be able to get some today (Decathlon, Halfords, Evans, large local indie) only seem to sell plastic pedals you can’t fit toe clips too, or clipless pedals, or the same sort of A5 sized pedal with pins in.

I can find what I want online but not to collect today - which makes me think ‘normal’ pedals don’t sell well.

My question (if there is one - tbh this post is more of a vent) is how come the marketing won so effectively that it’s harder to find normal pedals to wear with normal shoes than it is to find pedals that require special shoes?

All, any recommendations.
 

Drago

Legendary Member
Fashion is a fickle mistress.
 

Gwylan

Guru
Location
All at sea⛵
With you on this.
As a commuter, wanderer and do not want to be bothered with clips and special shoes. Especial those that make you sound like an arthritic donkey in the coffee shop.

I have some RockBros, Chinese fake for cheap, removable pedals.
Do two jobs, really handy, park in a confined space. Also your bike will only be stolen by very low IQ thief who does not understand the significance of the lack of pedals on a bike.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/26605775...ar=565913235102&widget_ver=artemis&media=MORE
 

Fastpedaller

Über Member
With you on this.
As a commuter, wanderer and do not want to be bothered with clips and special shoes. Especial those that make you sound like an arthritic donkey in the coffee shop.

I have some RockBros, Chinese fake for cheap, removable pedals.
Do two jobs, really handy, park in a confined space. Also your bike will only be stolen by very low IQ thief who does not understand the significance of the lack of pedals on a bike.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/26605775...ar=565913235102&widget_ver=artemis&media=MORE

Are they fake? I have some of those and they (and the seller) appear to be legit.
 

fossyant

Ride It Like You Stole It!
Location
South Manchester
If you want pedals that will take toe clips you are going to have to look on-line. Things moved on at least 40 years ago - not used clips for that long. Most 'flat' pedals do tend to be MTB type - that's what sells, but they will wreck your shoes. Boggo flats can be bought, the type that come with cheaper bikes but, not set up for clips.
 
In my case the reason to have pins on the pedals was emphasised quite often when my foot came off
and the pedal made sure I was aware of it by continuing round and smashing into my ankle/leg on its return

I can see you point about the shoes
I have found that the soles on trainers have become softer over the years
especially for more "everyday" type trainers
so the sharper edged pedal that I have had were ripping the soles apart much more than they did with harder soled shoes when I was a kid

Some years ago my wife bought me some all purpose cycling shoes

the sole is hard and the pedal pins do not rip them
but they look like normal shoes and I can walk in them like normal shoes
 
OP
OP
KneesUp

KneesUp

Guru
With you on this.
As a commuter, wanderer and do not want to be bothered with clips and special shoes. Especial those that make you sound like an arthritic donkey in the coffee shop.

I have some RockBros, Chinese fake for cheap, removable pedals.
Do two jobs, really handy, park in a confined space. Also your bike will only be stolen by very low IQ thief who does not understand the significance of the lack of pedals on a bike.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/26605775...ar=565913235102&widget_ver=artemis&media=MORE

I did think about removable ones, but I have a decent safe place at work, and at home, so there is no need really. I think if I ever need to use my folder again I'd be tempted to get some though because the folding ones never feel very rigid to me.

I'm after something like a Wellgo R110b with those half-toe clips - it just seems ridiculous that I live within 10 minutes of a Decathlon, Halfords and an Evans and yet I can't get what to me looks like a generic pedal that looks like what you'd get if you asked a non-cyclist to sketch a bike pedal.

I guess I'll order online and in the meantime swap the pedals I have been using on the other bike. Or try for a few days to remember not to lift the pedals with my toe so I don't scratch my shoes.
 

Dag Hammar

Über Member
Location
Essex
I have a pair like these Wellgo pedals. There are holes to fix toe clips to. Out of the four bikes that I have, one bike has pedals that I cannot fit toe clips to and I do miss them when I ride that bike. Of course, I too could treat myself to a new pair of pedals.
https://www.tredz.co.uk/.Wellgo-All...qO3QkV00qaF7vOJL903z5IsOOCZTNM2QaAioaEALw_wcB
 
Last edited:

fossyant

Ride It Like You Stole It!
Location
South Manchester
I couldn't get new canti pads last September - needed them desperately as we were about to go bike packing the next day and found one of the pads had snapped at the pin. None in Decathlon or Halfords. Called in at the LBS, they had a set !
 
Top Bottom