Are cycling shoes necessary , if so why ?

Discussion in 'General Cycling Discussions' started by woodbutcher, 14 Jun 2019.

Tags:
  1. woodbutcher

    woodbutcher Veteran

    Location:
    S W France
    Just wondering since l have never owned or used a pair....am l missing out . To be fair l am not competing in any way (except with myself) !
    All opinions and expertise welcome .
     
    MartinQ and Illaveago like this.
  2. roubaixtuesday

    roubaixtuesday Senior Member

    I was talked into when buying a mtb years ago. LBS was so sure it was a good idea, they have me them half price to convince me!

    They were right, much better to cycle in than normal shoes.

    But I'm a big fan of pedals with flats on one side, spds on the other, which means you can have the best of both worlds - just jump on if going down the shops, but get the advantages of clipped in for longer rides.
     
  3. MichaelW2

    MichaelW2 Veteran

    Shoes need to be a bit stiffer than typical running shoes but cycle race shoes need to resist the pedalling force of a professional sprinter, which is overkill for the average commuter.
    Tourists and used traicommutets havel shoes which are stiffer than running shoes but have more flex than cycling race shoes. These work perfectly well under normal pedalling on flat pedals and are better for walking. MTB shoes vary from race to trail in stiffness. I had some Shimano casual ones that were similar to trail shoes.
    You also have to consider the walkability, grip pattern and slipperyness of the sole material on eg wet stone or metal.
     
  4. Smudge

    Smudge Senior Member

    Location:
    Somerset
    I wouldn't ever use them, i like footwear that is good for walking around in when i park the bike.
    Trainers with shorts in summer, lightweight hiking boots with long trousers in winter.
     
    skudupnorth, MarkF, tyred and 4 others like this.
  5. I like Skol

    I like Skol Hold my beer and watch this....

    Location:
    Ashton-under-Lyne
    Yes, absolutely not.

    Someone will be along shortly to deride any suggestion that being clipped in gives any benefits while others can prove there is an 13% improvement in power transfer from using the right shoes while clipped in. I have used SPDs for around..... 25+ yrs (gosh! :eek:) and have no idea if it helps with power but I do know I like the surety of being securely connected to the bike and prefer the stiffer soles. I can ride in normal shoes or trainers but don't find the flexy sole so pleasant and dislike the way my foot position can alter.
     
  6. fossyant

    fossyant Ride It Like You Stole It!

    Location:
    South Manchester
    It's the stiff soles that make cycling more comfortable, and the fact your foot is in the right position. Also, on my MTB, it stops crank arm rub, which looks terrible (that's my OCD):laugh:
     
    meta lon, jay clock, Vantage and 4 others like this.
  7. fossyant

    fossyant Ride It Like You Stole It!

    Location:
    South Manchester
    I will potter about with normal trainers, but they aren't comfortable with clipless pedals (which is on every bike). I have, however, bought some SPD trainers for such occasions now - e.g. family bike rides to the pub.
     
    woodbutcher likes this.
  8. MichaelW2

    MichaelW2 Veteran

    Cycling shoes are stiffer than eveyday shoes to resist bending under pedalling force but race shoes are designed to resist the force of professional sprinters.
    For everyday riders, trail walking shoes provide sufficient resistance to bending and have been used by commuters and tourists for long distances.
    If you prefer to be clipped into your pedals, some of the more casual MTB styles give better walkability and grip on slick surfaces. Beware the hard plastic soles which only grip off road.
     
    woodbutcher likes this.
  9. HarryTheDog

    HarryTheDog Veteran

    Location:
    Basildon Essex
    A coincidence you posted this, a work colleague of mine just walked in this morning and said "now I know why you wear those cleated shoes " his foot had slipped of the pedal in the wet and smashed his knee into the handlebars this morning.
     
    si_c, gavroche, ColinJ and 3 others like this.
  10. MontyVeda

    MontyVeda a short-tempered ill-controlled small-minded troll

    Never had any either but don't feel like i'm missing out. Just another product to flog to people with a hobby... a bit like cycling socks.
     
  11. MontyVeda

    MontyVeda a short-tempered ill-controlled small-minded troll

    he needs better pedals.
     
    si_c, tyred and Illaveago like this.
  12. simongt

    simongt Über Member

    Location:
    Norwich
    Cycling shoes are a very personal thing; some love 'em, others just can't get on with them. If you plan on cycling any distance on a regular basis, then the stiffer shank of a cycling shoe will be more comfortable. There are oodles of shapes, designs etc. on the market suitable for platform, clipless and so on. so have a good look at what's available and decide which will suit you best. :thumbsup:
     
    woodbutcher and raleighnut like this.
  13. Crackle

    Crackle Squatter

    I ride a mtn bike unclipped with sturdy outdoor shoes and flat pedals. I ride my touring bike in any old shoes and flat pedals except when I put my clipped pedals on and ride with bike shoes and I always ride my road bike in clipped pedals.

    Some advantages to clips is your foot stays in position and doesn't slide off in the rain and wet or when you hit a bump, the same doesn't happen on a mtn bike because I'm generally out the saddle and weighting the pedals. Touring is more relaxed so I don't much worry about things but I do have to change my foot position more as it moves around on the pedal.

    Only once, when I rode a borrowed bike in running shoes for a good while, pushing hard did I suffer foot pain the next day, in fact i could hardly walk, the balls of my feet were in agony. Never happened since though.
     
  14. Phaeton

    Phaeton Guru

    Location:
    Oop North (ish)
    I like cycling socks
     
  15. davidphilips

    davidphilips Über Member

    Location:
    Onabike
    Only my opinion, they are not necessary you your self manage with out them, but having said that i think you are missing out, on some club runs i can just pull up and rest a bit to recover as long as the others are not going to fast and i find that theres a big benefit going up hill with cleats on.

    Personally i use road bike shoes but there are many that like sdp pedals because mtb shoes are far better to walk on, so again just my view but for very short distances they are not worth it but if you cycle a lot of miles then money well spent.
     
    Paulus likes this.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice