Are we being forced to go electric?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
Most people need 1 or 2 seaters with some luggage space and maybe occasional access to a larger vehicle.
Much smaller, adequate performance EV vehicles surely must be the way forward.
That's why self driving is the future. Need a mahoosive car to go to the airport - done. Need a small car to nip to the shops or pick the kids up from school? No problem. In the meantime, people will buy cars that match their use cases. For the majority of us that's an SUV or family type car.
 

Milkfloat

An Peanut
Location
Midlands
Kendal to Carlisle is 45 miles. I can't imagine any return journey in Cumbria is going to be much over 100 miles and there are loads of public charging points. So why is your use case exceptional?
It was a comment about public transport, not about EV viability.
 

MrGrumpy

Huge Member
Location
Fly Fifer
That's why self driving is the future. Need a mahoosive car to go to the airport - done. Need a small car to nip to the shops or pick the kids up from school? No problem. In the meantime, people will buy cars that match their use cases. For the majority of us that's an SUV or family type car.
I admire your optimism but take the rose tinted glasses off. Long long way off What you envisage as being the norm !
 
Last edited:
I admire your optimism but take the rose tinted glasses off. Long long way off What you envisage as being the norm !
It'll probably come quicker than you think.
Roads are getting silly for congestion now.
Parking is a nightmare.
The next generation won't be able to afford their own cars - not with the price of housing.
It'll make more sense for them to use self driving Ubers rather than have a car of their own sitting doing nothing for 99% of the time.
 

SpokeyDokey

68, & my GP says I will officially be old at 70!
Moderator
Kendal to Carlisle is 45 miles. I can't imagine any return journey in Cumbria is going to be much over 100 miles and there are loads of public charging points. So why is your use case exceptional?

Firstly: we were talking about a properly integrated public transport system not EV point to point use.

Secondly, Kendal to Carlisle is a simple journey. Try: a bit North of Kendal to say Wasdale Head (something I do 3 or 4 times a year plus other similar journeys) and give me a public transport option that works - or even sketch out an integrated solution for me.
 
Firstly: we were talking about a properly integrated public transport system not EV point to point use.

Secondly, Kendal to Carlisle is a simple journey. Try: a bit North of Kendal to say Wasdale Head (something I do 3 or 4 times a year plus other similar journeys) and give me a public transport option that works - or even sketch out an integrated solution for me.
What would you have done 50 years ago ? I'm afraid you'll always struggle for public transport out in the countryside.
 

MrGrumpy

Huge Member
Location
Fly Fifer
It'll probably come quicker than you think.
Roads are getting silly for congestion now.
Parking is a nightmare.
The next generation won't be able to afford their own cars - not with the price of housing.
It'll make more sense for them to use self driving Ubers rather than have a car of their own sitting doing nothing for 99% of the time.
Self driving cars do nothing for congestion. It’s going to get more and more congested. I really don’t see the obsession with self driving vehicles ?? That’s less jobs , what’s good about that ??
 

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
Self driving cars do nothing for congestion. It’s going to get more and more congested. I really don’t see the obsession with self driving vehicles ?? That’s less jobs , what’s good about that ??
"They're closing ;t pits - that's fewer jobs, what's good about that?"
"They've got motorized carriages - the grooms and breeders are going to be put out of jobs - what's good about that?"
"These new automated exchanges- the operators'll be out of work - what's good about that?"
"These new harvesting machines - the pickers'll be out of work - what's good about that?"

and so on...

Jobs are obsoleted all the time.

Self driving cars reduce congestion as fewer people need to buy cars.
 

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
Firstly: we were talking about a properly integrated public transport system not EV point to point use.

Secondly, Kendal to Carlisle is a simple journey. Try: a bit North of Kendal to say Wasdale Head (something I do 3 or 4 times a year plus other similar journeys) and give me a public transport option that works - or even sketch out an integrated solution for me.
Yep - sorry - apologies - didn't read properly and I entirely agree with you. Whilst you might get clusters of self driving cars in Carlisle and Kendall, you'd have to plan ahead a lot to go off the beaten track , and other public transport just wouldn't be viable.
 

classic33

Leg End Member
"They're closing ;t pits - that's fewer jobs, what's good about that?"
"They've got motorized carriages - the grooms and breeders are going to be put out of jobs - what's good about that?"
"These new automated exchanges- the operators'll be out of work - what's good about that?"
"These new harvesting machines - the pickers'll be out of work - what's good about that?"

and so on...

Jobs are obsoleted all the time.

Self driving cars reduce congestion as fewer people need to buy cars.
If self driving/automated cars start appearing in large numbers, then expect the number of them on the road to increase.

A major selling point is that you'll have fewer stops, due in part to the fact that they'll follow the lead vehicle at a given distance at a similar speed, at a closer spacing than "would be safe" with a driver in control. Their speed being limited to the type of road they are on. You end up with more cars taking up less space on the roads. That "empty space" will be taken up by other vehicles.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom