Discussion in 'Helmet Discussions' started by Hutch118, 26 Jul 2015.
I'll let you know
Perhaps the shoulder impact absorbed enough energy to take the impact on the ear into the range where a helmet might help.
Glad you're ok. I wear a helmet, feel much safer with one. Seems plenty of people don't by the ever so subtle remarks on this thread i know of a guy at the local hospital who came off his bike and smacked his head off the ground. Been in a coma ever since. Would he be in a coma if he had been wearing a helmet? Who knows! But I feel safer wearing one. Preference I guess
Second that, and wearing the one that has suffered the impact might make things worse next time.
http://www.bhsi.org/replace.htm for some help regards replacing it
It's a matter of faith. Some people bank on a St Christopher, or a rabbit's foot.
A consultants view on helmets
'There are accidents where helmets are a great thing. There are others where a helmet doesn’t work' - hospital consultant
"Recent research here shows that in direct impacts between cyclists and cars, the main areas of injury are to the torso or lower limbs, and a helmet offers little extra protection
But it is in secondary impacts – usually with the ground, or windscreen, or bonnet – that the helmet provides significant protection.
In 26 out of 32 secondary impact cases, helmets would have reduced the cyclists’ head injury by around 75pc, the research cited by the European Transport Safety Council (ETSC) shows."
does it take account the extra numbers of impacts due to head being bigger? Or the extra number of accidents due to closer passing by cars? Would it be the same ratio for pedestrians?
And is there any explanation for why this effect doesn't seem to happen in Australia or Ontario where there's compulsion.
For what it's worth I used to wear one, long before they were trendy, and extolled the benefits. Then I actually did some reading on it, and no longer wear one
You keep posting this link, which seems to be an article behind a firewall by some anonymous Irish hospital consultant. Not very helpful.
Can't tell if thats saying helmets are good or bad?? Lol. Either way, down to preference!
You have read the linked article I take it?
No of course not :-)
EDIT : against me better judgement I have read it now. Better than some but no evidence - just "an expert said" , then some facts not related to the conclusion. To be fair it was just a newspaper article. And no predictably, it doesn't mention any of my questions
It's a matter of faith. That's the only explanation for the evangelical zeal with which people who believe in helmets keep going on and on about them.
Consultants view on them. The person who treats the injuries when in A&E.
Separate names with a comma.