Another energy meter post.

Page may contain affiliate links. Please see terms for details.

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
1. Having a friend in the billing side of the energy business who recommended waiting for at least 3rd gen' of 'Smart meters' to become common before trusting the tech. I'm still awaiting his nod to go ahead. His boss had a trial 3G unit installed in his home and the fact that he had it removed speaks volumes.
Do post some links to this 3rd generation of Smart Meter that your friend mentions. As far as I can see, no such item exists or is planned for.


3. I didn't trust the tech, and more importantly for the providers to play fair. The recent pre-pay fiasco reinforces my distrust.
Why? What is there not to trust?

4. The 'terrible inconvenience' of reading and submitting readings every 3 or 6 months is such that I do it without even breaking sweat. (I must be exceedingly fit! So much so, that I do it every month.)
It's not about that. It's about the convenience of having meter readings every 30 minutes for gas and pretty much in real time for electricity. This allows your energy company to plan better, National Grid to plan better and in theory helps lower your energy costs as it can also help you to plan better. Expect to be excluded from some cheaper tariffs if you don't have a smart meter.
 

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
There's also the facility for the energy companies to remotely switch people to a prepayment scheme.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-63554879

Yes. People like this lady who failed to pay her bills and did not communicate with her supplier. I do wish they'd stop calling it a prepayment meter. The meter hasn't changed, just the payment method.

So yes, if you routinely don't pay your bills and don't respond to phone calls or e-mails from your supplier, you may well get switched to a prepayment method.
 

raleighnut

Legendary Member
You might as well do that with every other electrical appliance as well then.
Why, the sound quality of my fridge doesn't change..............also modern HiFi gear sounds crap most of the time, I know I've heard a few at friends/work colleagues houses in fact you need to spend rather a lot of money to even approach the sound of my set-up. There are exceptions like Sugden, Naim and Linn to name a few (there are others too) but most modern (mainly Japanese) Hifi I find too harsh and 'spitty/shouty' so that after a while they become wearing alright if you just have em on quiet as background music but not for long time listening pleasure.
You should have a word with Prof. Richard Wiseman, he's a psychologist who specialises in blind trials debunking 'connoisseurs' like art/wine/HiFi buffs who claim they can tell the difference between one product and another.
Yep most people do not have the palate/hearing to tell the difference, oh and BTW I'm not one of those who pays hundreds if not thousands of pounds on interconnects or speaker cables as long as they are of suitable quality the difference is minimal for instance my speaker cable is QED 79 strand at less than a pound a metre so for 4 x 5 metre lengths less than £20
 

icowden

Veteran
Location
Surrey
Isn't the 3G network being turned off in the UK by nearly all providers, this year, rendering the meters useless.
Yes and no. The meters will be fine. The hub modem may need an upgrade though.
Wow a vague article from 2015 about a Korean manufacturing company. Not sure what it is telling us, or if these "3rd gen" meters will ever be produced and if they are, whether they are any different for the consumer than a SMETS 2 meter,
 

classic33

Leg End Member
Yes and no. The meters will be fine. The hub modem may need an upgrade though.

Wow a vague article from 2015 about a Korean manufacturing company. Not sure what it is telling us, or if these "3rd gen" meters will ever be produced and if they are, whether they are any different for the consumer than a SMETS 2 meter,
Reliance on a network that's soon to be switched off in the UK, by most mobile operators.

And some of it's from 2014 as well.

Conference held in Lyon.
 
Last edited:
OP
OP
stephec

stephec

Legendary Member
Location
Bolton
Having read similar communications from two different suppliers I have steadfastly refused to have a smart meter. Why you ask?
1. Having a friend in the billing side of the energy business who recommended waiting for at least 3rd gen' of 'Smart meters' to become common before trusting the tech. I'm still awaiting his nod to go ahead. His boss had a trial 3G unit installed in his home and the fact that he had it removed speaks volumes.
2. I know that, if I switch the heat on, or use power to do anything, it will cost money, and I also know that something drawing 13amps uses 13 times the energy of something rated 1amp.
3. I didn't trust the tech, and more importantly for the providers to play fair. The recent pre-pay fiasco reinforces my distrust.
4. The 'terrible inconvenience' of reading and submitting readings every 3 or 6 months is such that I do it without even breaking sweat. (I must be exceedingly fit! So much so, that I do it every month.)

If the big deal about smart meters is that I know exactly what I'm using then point 2 here sums up perfectly why I don't really need one.
 

Alex321

Veteran
Location
South Wales
If the big deal about smart meters is that I know exactly what I'm using then point 2 here sums up perfectly why I don't really need one.

You don't need one unless you are wanting to start exporting and being paid for it.

But there is not really any significant downside to having one, and it may help you a little.

It is expected to help the country as a whole when just about everybody has one.
 

MrGrumpy

Huge Member
Location
Fly Fifer
Do post some links to this 3rd generation of Smart Meter that your friend mentions. As far as I can see, no such item exists or is planned for.



Why? What is there not to trust?


It's not about that. It's about the convenience of having meter readings every 30 minutes for gas and pretty much in real time for electricity. This allows your energy company to plan better, National Grid to plan better and in theory helps lower your energy costs as it can also help you to plan better. Expect to be excluded from some cheaper tariffs if you don't have a smart meter.

To be fair I don’t know what the problem is with smart meters . I can see exactly what I’m spending or have spent ? However to be fair before this energy crisis I probably didn’t give too hoots about the readings ! One thing though it saves sending in meter readings and estimate bills !!
 
Isn't the 3G network being turned off in the UK by nearly all providers, this year, rendering the meters useless.

Third Generation Smart Meters

There's been a lot of comments which sadly haven't led to a meaningful debate regarding the frequencies that the networks operate on interfering with the measurements of various pollutants as they emit frequencies that are in a similar range which risks skewing the data.
 

MontyVeda

a short-tempered ill-controlled small-minded troll
1st gen. smart meters weren't very smart, so they came up with the 2nd gen. These too have their issues (many listed on several threads here at CC). I told Eon that trusted neither the 1st or 2nd gen. smart meters and will wait for the 3rd gen and see what consumer feedback on those is like, and if it continues to be poor, I'll wait for the 4th gen. They haven't asked me since about getting a smart meter fitted... and they certainly didn't say there won't be a 3rd gen.
 
IIt does need to be pointed out that some of the 1st Gen smart meters just needed a software upgrade to become 2nd Gen meters
A software upgrade that can be done over the network

Mine was like that
Exactly why I had to pester then for a few years before they did it - in spite of their website saying how wonderful it was to have a smart meter and several companies promising to do it - has yet to be explained

But once someone bothered trying it just became a 2nd gen meter - when I checked the make and model it turned out that it was always capable of being either!
 

classic33

Leg End Member
Some more houses were blown up today, on the news, due to gas leakage. Is it getting a more regular occurrence?
Are more folks getting increasingly desperate and resorting to attempting bypassing?
Possible, but another possible may be that many gas supply routes into houses are no longer known. This includes the larger gas mains.
 

raleighnut

Legendary Member
Possible, but another possible may be that many gas supply routes into houses are no longer known. This includes the larger gas mains.

Yep, I lived in a complex of Flats,Maisonettes and Houses* on London rd in Stoneygate Leicester (posh area) self managed by a 'Residents Committee' with well tended communal gardens called Oliver Court, nice place built in the 70's. One day they were renewing the gas mains on the road that was the rear entrance to the place and also access to the residents garages and car parking and cut off the gas supply to the middle section (where we lived) after a couple of days with no heating the contractors were contacted and the British Gas representative informed the committee that "You don't have gas" and was most surprised when he was told "why are we paying gas bills then" cue much red faces and the supply being reconnected to the 10 flats and 8 maisonettes in the centre block that had 'forced air' central heating.

My point being that this wasn't some ancient place that had been renovated but a modernish complex and this was also before privatisation when if you had gas it was British Gas as the only supplier and they still hadn't got the maps right of where the pipes ran underground and despite sending bills to the properties still didn't seem to know they supplied us.

* 30 flats on 3 floors as the front block, 8 ground floor flats with 3 bed maisonettes above and 1 1st floor flat (ours) and 1 2nd floor flat above us in the centre block and 10 4 bed terraced houses on the rear block
 
Top Bottom